The Business Court has granted summary judgment to an oil trader in a breach of contract with a pipeline operator.
DK Trading & Supply, LLC v. Wink to Webster Pipeline LLC (2026 Tex. Bus. 76; October 28, 2026) arose from a dispute over contracts involving the transportation and storage of oil. Wink executed a terminal agreement with Delek W2W, LLC (Delek). Wink agreed to provide specified storage capacity for Delek’s crude oil, to maintain connection with the pipeline, to accept crude oil meeting either the Pipeline Tariff’s quality specifications or Delek’s unique specifications, and to stage deliveries to the pipeline. Delek agreed to reimburse Wink for specified operating and maintenance costs, to make a monthly terminal service payment, to provide minimum crude-oil inventory, and to make nominations as provided under the transportation agreement. Pursuant to the transportation agreement, Wink promised to receive Delek’s nominated volumes of crude oil and deliver equivalent volumes at specified destination points. In return, Delek promised to ship its volume commitment each true-up period or pay a deficiency payment, to pay Wink’s invoices timely, and to tender product meeting the Tariff’s quality specifications.
Delek (which assigned its rights to DK Trading) filed suit. It moved for traditional summary judgment, alleging that Wink breached the terminal agreement by failing to provide exclusive use of two Delek tanks for crude-oil storage. This failure allegedly caused more than $10 million in losses to Delek. Delek further alleged that Wink breached and defaulted on the transportation agreement by overcharging Delek the deficiency payment in the amount of $451,961. Delek also asked for attorney’s fees.
In an opinion by Judge Sharp, the court partially granted the motion. Taking up Delek’s breach of the terminal agreement claim, the court observed that under its previous ruling construing the parties obligations under the contract, the terminal agreement required Wink to “provide services to Delek by providing the Storage Capacity for exclusive use by Delek to ship crude oil.” It further required Wink to provide storage in two tanks for the exclusive use of Delek at all times, “regardless of whether Delek is exercising its right to store Delek-grade oil and even if Wink now questions Delek’s need for its own tanks.” Delek offered inventory records showing that in every month from December 2021 to July 2026, the Delek tanks contained some volume of oil “even before Delek made any nominations to the Facility.” Wink did not rebut this evidence, nor did it claim “it substituted different tanks for the Delek Tanks under the Terminal Agreement.” In short, Wink had no “contractual justification that would allow third-party crude to be stored in” Delek’s tanks. The court thus ruled that “Wink’s use of the Tanks for third-party crude was a breach of the Terminal Agreement” and granted its MSJ on that issue.
As to Delek’s claim for $10 million in damages, however, the court determined that Wink had raised a fact issue. Delek asserted a benefit-of-the-bargain theory based on the contractual amount it agreed to pay over the relevant contract period. The court, however, pointed out that
“Delek’s value received is the question, and it cannot be answered as a matter of law on this record.” Though Delek argued that it received no value, the court looked to Wink’s other other services promised under the contract, including “receiving, storing, and staging Delek’s crude for delivery, and Delek does not conclusively prove to what extend the Delek Tanks have been used for Delek’s own crude as compared to third parties’ crude.” Additionally, Delek for the most part opted to store on tariff grade oil as opposed to Delek grade oil. Wink’s expert testified with no objection that “there is no operational purpose or commercial benefit” to segregate tariff grade crude for storage. Delek thus failed to establish as a matter of law “the extent to which the contractual value of Delek’s storage was impaired by having to share its Tanks with third parties.” In addition to that, Wink’s evidence raised a fact issue “as to whether Delek has maintained its right to store its own, segregated Delek-grade crude—and as to whether that right has some value.” The court thus denied Delek’s MSJ on the damages issue.
Turning to the alleged overcharge on the transportation agreement, the court agreed with Delek. Under that agreement, Wink had to calculate Delek’s deficiency payment for each true-up period “by accounting for ‘every Barrel of Product actually shipped on the Pipeline during the True-Up Period,’ regardless of whether Delek paid for those shipments with previously accrued deficiency credits.” Delek conclusively provided that for the true-up period ending July 31, 2025, its shipments fell short of its volume commitment. According to the calculation, the deficiency amount multiplied by the contractual rate should have yielded just over $14,000, not $451,961. Wink thus breached the transporation agreement, and the court granted Delek’s MSJ on that issue.
The court rejected Wink’s argument that it raised a fact issue as to Delek’s MSJ claim that Wink defaulted on the transportation agreement.The court held that since Wink breached the agreement, it “‘fail[ed] to comply with [an] obligation[] under’ the Agreement, as defined by its default clause.” Wink also failed to meet the 60-day cure period, though it did credit back the overpayment following the court’s initial summary judgment ruling. But that didn’t moot the issue, as Wink argued, because its default “trigger[ed] the various remedies under the Transportation Agreement’s Section 12, including the nondefaulting party’s right to withhold Deficiency Payments, suspend performance, or terminate the contract.” The court granted Delek’s MSJ as to the transportation agreement.
Finally, the court carried over Delek’s request for attorney’s fees to trial on what was left of the lawsuit.












