The Eastland Court of Appeals has affirmed an Ector County district court’s dismissal of a medical malpractice lawsuit because Plaintiff’s amended expert report was deficient.

George Muns v. Kharvar Dar, M.D. (No. 11-25-00225-CV; September 24, 2026) arose from a health care liability claim. Plaintiff was intubated under emergency conditions at a hospital in Pecos. He was subsequently transferred to Odessa Regional Medical Center by air flight transport. Plaintiff alleged that because of inadequate sedation, he woke up in the critical care unit at OMRC while intubated. He removed both his orogastric and endotracheal tubes. A nurse called Plaintiff’s wife, his medical power of attorney, to report that Plaintiff was “sitting up in bed with [a] CPAP on and [was] grabbing at [the] mask, secondary to residual medication in his system, but [was] stable.” Plaintiff was then reintubated.

The next morning, two nurses performed an IV infusion. Plaintiff resisted, but the charge nurse allegedly told him that he had “lost [his] rights’ when he removed his intubations. Plaintiff claimed he lost control of his gag reflex and vomited into the tubes. The hospital staff allegedly “scrambled” to clear his airways while Plaintiff struggled against his restraints. Defendant physician arrived a few minutes later. He allegedly “berated” Plaintiff and threatened to hold him for two weeks. However, the hospital decided to extubate and release him against medical advice. Plaintiff sued the physician, hospital, and others and served an expert report. Defendants objected and moved to dismiss. The trial granted the motion. On appeal, the court of appeals determined that Plaintiff was entitled to a thirty-day extension to cure the deficiencies. Plaintiff served an amended report, but the trial court again granted Defendant’s motion to dismiss. Plaintiff appealed.

In an opinion by Justice Trotter, the court of appeals affirmed. Plaintiff argued that the amended report identified “the causal relationship between the failure (1) to administer an anesthetic other than Propofol, which caused him harm ‘from’ the failed sedation to the non-consensual re-intubation to the alleged mistreatment during extubation[,]’ and (2) to obtain his informed consent.” Specifically, the report averred that Defendant told multiple providers that Plaintiff had a history of waking up while Propofol was being administered, requiring the use of a different medication.

The court was not persuaded. Plaintiff’s expert “merely opined that had the proper medication been given, [Plaintiff] would not have sustained any injuries. However, and importantly, it does not explain how this omission caused [Plaintiff’s] alleged injuries” (citations omitted). Plaintiff’s expert failed to link the proposition “that Propofol should not have been used [] to the alleged injuries Plaintiff sustained because of his self-extubation.” Plaintiff further argued that because Defendant didn’t “disclose or adequately disclose the risks and hazards involved in the medical care or surgical procedure rendered,” there had to be “a causal connection showing that the risks complained of ‘could have influenced a reasonable person in making a decision to give or withhold consent.” But the expert report “contain[ed] no reference as to whether possessing the requisite information would have influenced a reasonable person to withhold consent. Instead, his report only references whether [Plaintiff’s] wife would have withheld consent.” Without an explicit discussion of what a reasonable person would have done under the circumstances, the amended report’s causation analysis didn’t constitute a good faith effort to comply with Chapter 74.”

The court concluded by rejecting Plaintiff’s request for an additional extension to cure the deficiencies in the amended report. According to the statute, Plaintiff was only entitled to a second bite, not a third. The court affirmed the trial court order dismissing the case.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This