We missed this decision in the summer, so apologies for the delayed response. In this important decision, a divided Houston [1st] Court of Appeals held that the asbestos/silica MDL court rules didn’t apply to claims filed before September 1, 2003, if claimants had been diagnosed, as shown by a medical report, with malignant mesothelioma.

In re Deloris Jones, Individually and as Representative of the Estate of Willie Lee Jones (No. 01-24-00651; June 30, 2026) arose from a series of asbestos cases that were transferred from district courts in Jefferson and Orange County to the Asbestos Multi-District Litigation pretrial court in Harris County. Relators moved to remand, arguing that their actions were filed prior to September 1, 2003 and, consequently, the MDL didn’t apply. The pretrial court denied their motions. Relators sought mandamus relief.

In an opinion by Justice Rivas-Molloy, the court granted Relators’ petition. The question before the court was the construction of § 90.010(a), CPRC. This statute provides “that the multidistrict litigation (“MDL”) ‘rules apply to any action pending on the date this chapter becomes law [September 1, 2005] in which claimant alleges personal injury or death from exposure to asbestos or silica’ unless one of three exceptions apply.” Pursuant to those exceptions, the MDL rules don’t apply if: (1) the action was prior to September 1, 2003, and trial has commenced or set to commence before the 90th day after the effective date; (2) the action was filed before September 1, 2003, and the claimant serves a compliant medical report on or before the 90th day after the effective date; or (3) the action was filed before September 1, 2003, and the exposed person has been diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma, other than malignant asbestos-related cancer. The statute provides further that if the claimant doesn’t serve a compliant report on or before the 90thday after the effective date, the defendant may file a notice of transfer to the MDL pretrial court. In 2005 SCOTX adopted Rules of Judicial Administration 13.11, which applies to pre-September 1, 2003 claims.

The four underlying actions were filed in Jefferson and Orange County in 1995. In August 2017, Relators amended their petitions to add as defendants several insurance carriers, including Real Party in Interest Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. Nationwide filed a notice of transfer in October 2017 under Rule 13.11, characterizing the actions as “tag-along” cases. Relators moved to remand and attached § 90.003(a) medical reports. (Those reports were originally served in December 2021 and early 2022.) The reports stated that all four Relators were diagnosed with mesothelioma and all died in 1995, 2002, 2000, and 1990. Relators therefore contended that their cases were exempt from the MDL rules. Real Parties responded that the rules applied because Relators didn’t file their medical reports “on or before the 90th day after” September 1, 2005, the effective date of Chapter 90.

In a prior iteration of this case, the court of appeals held that Relators’ cases were not exempt from the MDL because they had not established their diagnoses of malignant mesothelioma in a medical report. This time around Relators filed amended motions to remand with medical reports showing that all four of them had been diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma in or before 2002. But they weren’t filed on or before the 90th day after September 1, 2005.

Turning to statutory construction, the court walked through the text of § 90.010(a) and concluded that “[u]nder the plain terms of [the statute], the MDL rules are not applicable to Relators’ actions.” When Chapter 90 became effective, Relators had already been diagnosed with malignant meso. The applicable statutory exception requires nothing more, as long as Relators established their diagnoses. Real Parties didn’t dispute that Relators filed their cases before September 1, 2003 or that they had diagnosed malignant mesothelioma in or before 2022. But they argued that the court “should construe that section to impose yet a third requirement: (3) that the malignant diagnosis be established through a Section 90.003(a) report filed ‘on or before the 90th day after the date this chapter becomes law.” The court declined to read that language into the statute, or to rule that § 90.010(b) overrides the independent exception in § 90.010(a)(3). And as the court pointed out, § 90.010(b) expressly applies only to 90.010(a)(2), not (a)(3).

The court thus held that the MDL court erred in denying Relators’ motions to remand. The court further ruled that Relators didn’t have an adequate remedy at law because their cases didn’t belong in the MDL to begin with.

Justice Dokupil filed a dissenting opinion, which was published on October 30. He would have held that the statute was ambiguous, and the trial court’s interpretation was reasonable.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This