No Regulation
by Litigation
15th Court of Appeals Overturns TC Order Reversing TCEQ Issuance of Wastewater Permit to Developers
The 15th Court of Appeals has reversed a Travis County district court ruling that substantial evidence did not support a TCEQ order granting a wastewater permit to...
Business Court Enforces Mutual Waiver Agreement Between Operators of Adjacent Leases
In a third opinion by Judge Bullard arising from the same dispute, the Business Court has granted in part and denied in part an defendant operator’s motion for...
Business Court Enforces Mutual Waiver Agreement Between Operators of Adjacent Leases
In a opinion by Judge Bullard arising from the same dispute, the Business Court has granted an operator’s motion for summary judgment on its breach-of-contract...
SCOTX Reverses Appraisal Award Based on Evident Partiality Rule
The Texas Supreme Court ha reversed a trial court order confirming an appraisal award where a neutral appraiser failed to disclose prior to his appointment that one...
Business Court Rejects Oil and Gas Leasholder’s Attempt to Claim Third-Party Beneficiary Status under Waiver Agreement Between Operators
In an opinion by Judge Bullard, the Business Court has granted a defendant operator’s plea to the jurisdiction on the basis that Plaintiff leaseholder was not a...
Business Court Applies Anti-Fracturing Rule to Dismiss Legal Malpractice, Fraud, and Other Claims Added to Case After Removal
The Business Court has dismissed for lack of jurisdiction a legal malpractice claim, as well as numerous fraud and breach of fiduciary duty claims under the...
Dallas Court of Appeals Affirms Take-Nothing Judgment for Defendants in Wrongful Death Case
The Dallas Court of Appeals has upheld a trial court’s take-nothing judgment in a workplace fatality case in which the jury found that the decedent was 51%...
SCOTX Throws Out Candidate’s Suit to Compel RPT to Put Him on the Ballot
In a per curium opinion, SCOTX has rejected former Justice Steven Wayne Smith’s petition for writ of mandamus seeking placement on the Republican Party primary...
Fort Worth Court of Appeals Affirms TC Order Denying Chapter 74 Motion to Dismiss for Deficient Expert Report
Based on the health care providers’ failure to preserve their objections to the plaintiffs’ supplemental expert report, the Fort Worth Court of Appeals has had no...
15th Court of Appeals Affirms TC Dismissal of Insured’s Suit Against TRS, Blue Cross Based on Sovereign Immunity
Regina Carson v. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas, Inc., et al. (No. 15-24-00108-CV; December 18, 2025) arose from a dispute between a public school teacher and Blue...
In Concurring Opinion, Justice Gunn Urges Prohibition on Pretext Instructions
Houston [1st] Court of Appeals Justice David Gunn has urged Texas appellate courts to rule that trial courts do not have discretion to submit pretext instructions that “single out one side’s take on key testimony and prod the jury to find for that side.” Though he...
Waco Court of Appeals Reverses TC Denial of Arbitration in Case Involving Incorporation by Reference Doctrine
The 10th Court of Appeals reversed a trial court order denying the motion to compel arbitration in a breach of contract dispute involving application of the incorporation by reference doctrine. Mitchell Constuction Company, Inc. v. Superior Commercial Concrete, LLC...
SCOTX Rejects Candidate’s Mandamus Petition Seeking Access to GOP Primary Ballot
In the second of two mandamus proceedings, the Texas Supreme Court has rejected a last-ditch effort by Supreme Court candidate David Rogers to land a spot on the GOP primary ballot. The court earlier denied a similar petition for writ of mandamus by former SCOTX...
Houston [1st] Court of Appeals Reverses $46 Million Judgment in Favor of Refinery Owner in Dispute with Contractor Over Indemnity Provision
The Houston [1st] Court of Appeals has held that an indemnity provision in a master contract between a refinery owner and a contractor did not impose a comparative indemnity obligation on the contractor. It thus reversed a $46 million judgment in favor of the owner....
Houston [1st] Court of Appeals Reverses Plaintiff’s Verdict in Truck Accident Case
The Houston [1st] Court of Appeals has reversed a $300,000 judgment against a beer distributor stemming from an accident involving one of its trucks because the plaintiff failed to establish that an allegedly defective tire substantially caused the accident. Houston...
TCJL PAC: Early 2026 Judicial Endorsements
TCJL PAC Early 2026 Judicial Endorsements November 2025 Judges are important. They have a direct impact on citizens, perhaps more than any other elected official, because they make decisions that can affect jobs, homes, businesses, children and personal freedoms. TCJL...
TCJL Legislative
Analysis Process
TCJL Journal
Spring 2024
Highlights
Chairman’s Column
George Christian Award: Tribute to Chief Justice Nathan Hecht
Rob Looney Award to Chairman Jeff Leach
Super Staffer Awards: Recognizing Outstanding Legislative Staff
- Lauren Young
- Drew Tedford
- Andrea Stingley
2023 Annual Meeting
2024 Annual Meeting
88th Legislative Session Report
- Part 1: TCJL Priority Bills Passed in the 88th Session
- Part 2: Civil Justice-Related Bills that Failed in 2023
- Part 3: How Did TCJL’s Statement of Conservative Business Principles Fare?
- Part 4: Eminent Domain Update
- Part 5: Special Session Report – Legislature Prohibits Vaccine Mandates
TPLF: Third Party Litigation Funding
Pandemic Liability Two Years On
Texas Judges
2024 Elections Report
What’s on the Web
Amicus Report












